Drives & data

Drive works on one computer but not another

This points to a difference in ports, drivers, or power between the two computers rather than the drive being broken, since it works somewhere.

Difficulty
Easy
Time
20–40 minutes
DIY cost
$0–$0
Pro cost
$60–$150

Symptoms

  • Drive is detected and works fine on Computer A
  • Same drive shows nothing or errors on Computer B
  • Both computers are otherwise functioning normally
  • Problem happens consistently, not randomly

Likely causes

  • CommonComputer B's USB port isn't supplying enough powerOlder or lower-power ports, especially on some laptops, can't run certain external drives.
  • CommonMissing or outdated USB/storage drivers on Computer BA fresh or outdated Windows install may lack a needed driver.
  • PossibleFile system incompatibility, like a Mac-formatted drive on a Windows PC without extra softwareSome formats need additional drivers to read on a different OS.
  • PossibleBIOS/UEFI settings on Computer B disabling certain USB or SATA modesLegacy vs. AHCI/USB settings can affect drive detection on some systems.

What to do

  1. Try the drive in multiple different ports on Computer B, including rear motherboard ports on a desktop.
  2. Check Device Manager on Computer B for warning icons related to USB controllers or storage.
  3. Confirm the drive's file system is one Computer B's operating system supports natively, or install the needed driver (e.g., for reading Mac-formatted drives on Windows).
  4. Update Computer B's chipset and USB drivers from the manufacturer's website.
  5. Check Computer B's BIOS/UEFI settings for anything related to USB or SATA mode that differs from Computer A.
  6. If Computer B genuinely can't detect any external drives at all, the issue may be with its hardware rather than this specific drive.

Safety

Generally low risk

Generally low risk for a careful person. Stop if anything looks different from what this guide describes.

Related guides

Operator provides AI-generated troubleshooting information. It can be wrong. For safety-critical, electrical, gas, structural, medical, automotive safety, or other high-risk problems, consult a qualified professional.